When mayonnaise runs out, Greek yogurt at 1:1 is the closest structural substitute — mayonnaise's creaminess comes from egg-lecithin emulsifying oil into droplets at pH 3.5–4.0, and Greek yogurt recreates that lipid-dispersed smooth texture through casein-stabilized fat at similar acidity, so potato salad, coleslaw, and sandwich spreads taste nearly identical. Sour cream at 1:1 is the most seamless swap for cooked and baked applications — both are emulsified tangy fats, and sour cream's acidity also activates baking soda for better rise in cakes. Mashed avocado at 2 tablespoons per 1 tablespoon of mayo is the best vegan option, matching spreadability through monounsaturated fat.
Substitutes
Aioli — 1:1 (aioli is garlic mayo — adds pungent garlic flavor; best for finishing spreads and sauces). Garlic-flavored mayonnaise with a richer, more aromatic profile. Both are egg-based oil emulsions with similar viscosity. Aioli adds a pungent garlic note that works well as a finishing spread.
Sour Cream — 1:1 for dressings, dips, and sandwiches; add 1 tsp lemon juice per cup if needed. Sour cream has similar creaminess with more tang and less fat. Works in dips, dressings, and sandwiches.
Greek Yogurt — 1:1 (stir well; Greek yogurt is thicker than mayo — thin with 1 tbsp milk per cup if needed). Greek yogurt is tangier and healthier. Excellent swap in dressings, dips, and chicken/tuna salads.
Plain Yogurt — 1:1 for cold dressings, dips, and coleslaw; drain excess whey first. Tangier and lighter with approximately half the fat of mayonnaise. Fermented dairy adds a pleasant acidity. Great in cold dressings, dips, and coleslaw where richness is not critical.
Avocado Oil — 3/4 cup avocado oil per 1 cup mayonnaise (in dressings). Avocado oil provides the fat component. Add lemon juice and salt. Only for dressing applications.