What can I substitute for Old Bay Seasoning?

The best substitutes for Old Bay Seasoning are: 1) Celery Salt (1 tsp celery salt + pinch paprika + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay), 2) Paprika (1 tsp paprika + 1/4 tsp celery-seed + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay), 3) Hot Paprika (1:1 plus pinch each of celery salt and black pepper).

What is the best Old Bay Seasoning substitute for cooking?

For cooking, the best substitute for Old Bay Seasoning is Celery Salt with a ratio of 1 tsp celery salt + pinch paprika + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay. Celery salt is Old Bay's base ingredient. Add paprika and cayenne for closer match.

What is a vegan substitute for Old Bay Seasoning?

A vegan substitute for Old Bay Seasoning is Celery Salt with a ratio of 1 tsp celery salt + pinch paprika + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay. This substitute is rated as a good match.

Substitute for Old Bay Seasoning - Best Alternatives

Iconic American blend of celery salt, paprika, and pepper. Essential for Maryland crab cakes and seafood boils.

Substitutes

Celery Salt — 1 tsp celery salt + pinch paprika + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay. Celery salt is Old Bay's base ingredient. Add paprika and cayenne for closer match.
Paprika — 1 tsp paprika + 1/4 tsp celery-seed + pinch cayenne per 1 tsp Old Bay. Paprika provides color and mild pepper. Add celery seed and cayenne for depth.
Hot Paprika — 1:1 plus pinch each of celery salt and black pepper. Hot paprika provides the base. Add celery salt and dry mustard for closer Old Bay flavor.